[Junk Sciences] About that Dr. Neides article published in Cleveland.com

I am sure you have now heard about the infamous opinion article published by Dr. Daniel Neides, MD (Cleveland Clinic) titled “Make 2017 the year to avoid toxins (good luck) and master your domain: Words on Wellness” and published in Cleveland.com, the online site of “The Plain Dealer”, a local newspaper (http://www.cleveland.com/lyndhurst-south-euclid/index.ssf/2017/01/make_2017_the_year_to_avoid_to.html).
What was sounding first as a silly title just in time for the post-holiday “detox diets” and other scientific fallacy, quickly spinned into a conspiracy nightmare. I would not have been surprised if it came from some quack doctors that make a living on selling supplements, books and other premium services.
What was the most concerning was this article came from a medical director from a highly regarded US Health Institute, as the article was signed as “Dr. Daniel Neides is the Medical Director and Chief Operating Officer of the Cleveland Clinic Wellness Institute.
You can check for yourself but the content of this opinion article was simply frightening (I am commenting on the article as it was published on 1/8/17 at 10:52AM.
LYNDHURST, Ohio–I am tired of all the nonsense we as American citizens are being fed while big business – and the government – continue to ignore the health and well-being of the fine people in this country. Why am I all fired up, you ask?
I, like everyone else, took the advice of the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) – the government – and received a flu shot. I chose to receive the preservative free vaccine, thinking I did not want any thimerasol (i.e. mercury) that the “regular” flu vaccine contains.
Makes sense, right? Why would any of us want to be injected with mercury if it can potentially cause harm? However, what I did not realize is that the preservative-free vaccine contains formaldehyde.”
The article first sentence just set the tone: Dr. Neides has a grief about Big Gov and Big Business in general. I am mad on the government too, but not for the same reasons. We have been facing one of the most polarized election with the two parties trenched into their ideological trenches, with the average Joe in the cross-fire. We cannot have a ruling government without having a bipartisan consensus that help find a common ground to move on.
Then things gets sour as he is fingerpointing on the CDC, again using the allusion of Big Gov for his grief on this institution. It quickly turns into a anti-vaccine diatribe, with spelling errors (it is “thimerosal/thiomersal” not “thimerasol”). Not only Dr.Neides fail to name his grief correctly (and you cannot blame autocorrect on that one) but also makes a scientifically fallacy by associating “thimerasol” as mercury. As previously mentioned in my blog, there is a huge difference between mercury as an element (Hg) and the organomercury compounds such as methylmercury (CH3Hg) and ethylmercury (CH3CH2Hg). Considering organic chemistry part of the pre-requisite courses for any medical school, this type of mistake is not acceptable.
In a common anti-vaccine move, Dr. Neides quickly played the “goalpost moving” tactic. If you first argument failed following its refutation by facts, move to another target and play the same spiel. If it is not thimerosal, then it is the formaldehyde. If it is not the formaldehyde, then it is the aluminum……..
We are not yet at the end of the first paragraph and already Dr. Neides has taken a dangerous slippery slope in pseudoscientific claims. He will continue into the “appeal to authority” fallacy, claiming the government is condoning the global population health. This is why the government has agencies like the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS), the Food and Drug Administration (FDA), the Center of Diseases Control (CDC) and the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). They have doing their job, could be better but it could be worse. Considering our next government line-up, we will likely soon regret how “red tapes” is sometimes needed.
But lets go to the second part of his article with this very interesting quote:
We live in a toxic soup. There are over 80,000 chemicals used in various industries country-wide. There are over 2,000 new chemicals being introduced annually. We breathe in these chemicals through exhaust, eat them in our processed foods ( just look at the labels that have 20 or 30 ingredients and good luck pronouncing their names), textiles (clothing, bedding, furniture), and personal care products, including make-up, deodorant, shampoos, and soaps.“.
Of course we are living in a chemical soup, but not all of them are toxic. There are some that are neutral, some are toxic (this is what we refer as poisons and toxins and are extensively studied by a discipline called toxicology) and some are even beneficial (these are identified by a a discipline called pharmacology).
Authorities are constantly testing these chemicals for 40 years now and there is a huge effort from international agencies to provide a formidable toxicological database to document the toxicity of any existing chemical inventoried.
A side-note, the quote “good luck pronouncing their names” sounds eerily familiar to a quote from a certain Babe “If a third grader can’t pronounce it, don’t eat it“. I am guessing I should ditch the addition of “alpha-D-glucopyrannosyl-1,4-alpha-D-fructofurannoside” from my morning cup of Joe. Thats by the way the biochemical name for sugar.
It is followed by a mishmash of different terms that just sound like a nightmare for anyone teaching pharmacokinetics to healthcare professional.
Toxins accumulate in our fat cells if they are not eliminated and interrupt normal bodily functions. Your body should be a finely tuned machine with all of the organ systems working in concert together. But when toxins disrupt normal function, problems can occur. Those problems include cancers, auto-immune diseases, neurologic problems like autism, ADHD, and Parkinson’s disease, and the most prevalent chronic diseases like obesity, diabetes, and heart disease (note: so high blood pressure is not a chronic disease, then?).
Why are we so sick in 2017 despite the best access to healthcare? The body has wonderful built-in systems to help us detoxify. The liver and kidneys try to do an exceptional job keeping up with filtering out the “stuff” (toxins included) we don’t need. Our skin – the largest organ in the body – will release toxins in the form of perspiration (what did they teach you in med school? How did you graduated from your biochemistry class?). Our breath will release toxins with each exhalation (same “boingboing” moment). When our gut is healthy and our microbiome (100 trillion organisms that live in our intestinal tract, within our airway, and on our skin) intact, our bowel movements help rid unwanted toxins.
I like to think of our detoxification system as a big bucket. As long as the toxic soup stays within the bucket, our body can naturally eliminate what we don’t need and help us live at the highest quality of life. But what happens when the bucket starts to overflow – which is exactly what many of us have been facing our entire lives? The body may not have the capacity to eliminate our current exposures and THAT IS WHEN BAD THINGS START TO OCCUR.”
We, as animals, have evolved to deal with many chemicals in nature that can have a possible threat to use. In pharmacokinetics, we refer to ADME for Absorption, Distribution, Metabolism and Elimination.
Absorption of compounds is limited for water-soluble compounds, they need a special door (called solute carriers) to enter inside your body. Now some (and many drugs in general) are fat-soluble (we call them lipophilic compounds) and can diffuse passively through the intestinal barrier and get into the bloodstream. Even if these drugs can make it through the gut, they have to face a firs-pass metabolism by the liver (we will discuss later about it) and deactivate some if not all of them. Those who were not affected by the first-pass are ongoing a distribution phase. Distribution occurs by the spread of the compounds throughout the central compartment (blood circulation). From this compartment, compounds can diffuse into peripheral (tissue) compartments. One of this compartment is named the “deep storage compartment” (a nice word for your fat tissue) that can retain some lipophilic drugs. As long as you ingest them, you can accumulate these compounds. Once you stop, these compounds move from the periphery back into the central compartment. We know which compounds can store (the lipophilic ones) and such feature is considered in toxicological studies to define if a compound is toxic or not. After circulating, compounds are perfusing through the liver and undergo of series of chemical reactions called metabolism. Metabolism is ensured by a series of enzymes grouped into two phases: Phase I enzymes (called cytochrome P450s or CYPs) and Phase II (conjugating) enzymes. Phase I enzymes transform compounds from a fat-soluble into a water-soluble compounds. Phase II enzymes tag these compounds to ease their elimination. Finally, the elimination phase is the one by which the body get rid of these compounds. There are two major routes: hepatobiliary (liver via the bile duct and eliminated via feces) and renal (kidneys).
Again, the fallacious claim that skin and respiration are considered as major elimination routes is simply outrageously wrong, especially considering from a healthcare professional.
The third part is directly playing the classical anti vaccine tropes “vaccines cause autism” that have debunked again and again.  I will not into it, there are great resources about what this claim is purely wrong and not supported by science.
But I just wanted to add my take on Hepatitis B (HepB) and newborns vaccination. The general public has a global misconception about HepB being only an STD. Indeed it is not. HepB is the same type of virus than HIV when we talk about mode of transmission: a blood-borne pathogen (in addition to its sexual transmission). This is a vaccine we highly recommend to any staff working in lab research and handling any blood or blood-based products. Because there is always a risk of HepB transmission via accidental cut and exposure to blood, this is even supported by being an “healthy carrier” (you have circulating HepB in your blood but you are not having any liver condition). it is better safe than sorry, considering than HepB can lead to severe liver pathology such as cirrhosis.
Finally the fourth part was fairly alarming. You may have heard about Orac, a seasoned MD and oncologist that is doing a great job in his website “www.sciencebasedmedicine.org“. Orac has been raising his concern that pseudoscience and quackery has been percolating inside mainstream medicine, using names like “functional medicine”, “integrative medicine” or “holistic medicine” as a wolf with a sheep cloth, appearing harmless.
He cites then a quote from a colleague named Jessica Hutchins, MD and IFM-certified (certification from a certain Institute of Functional Medicine) as described as the following:
In a 2015 article in U.S. News and World Report (Link to her article), Jessica Hutchins, M.D., IFM certified practitioner, states , “Information on eating toxin-free food and pushing food manufacturers to stop using harmful ingredients can be found at foodbabe.com. When we vote with our dollars by choosing to buy products that are sustainably produced and chemical-free, we actively shape the market place. Help change the way [loved ones] nourish their precious bodies, starting with yourself as an example.
Using Vani Hari (aka the FoodBabe) as a source of information and as a reference for health advices, from an MD, is simply insane! “What did they teach you at the IFM?”. At first glance, the certification program provided by the IFM seems legitimate (https://www.functionalmedicine.org/certification_program/About/) however one single item appear intriguing:
Comprehensive assessment of the fundamental physiological systems that organize the key clinical imbalances and are affected by the mental-emotional-spiritual core: Assimilation, Communication, Defense and repair, Transport, Energy, Structural Integrity, Biotransformation and elimination
Until now, we have little or no evidence of prayers and thoughts work in healing someone, lesser than any evidence faith healer healed someone solely on their spiritual powers. Also the presence of chiropractors as instructors (and we know how well chiropractors have a scientific training) is also disturbing.

In conclusion, 2017 comes in with a bang as I feared: a year in which evidence, facts are discredited by gut-feeling, smooth talks and snake oil sellers.

Post-scriptum: when you have woo peddlers lauding your article, you know that our article is a complete #NaturalNonSense (courtesy: Chow Babe).


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s