[Metal] Nightwish – Endless Forms Most Beautiful (90%)

Nightwish…..if you are in the metal scene you surely have heard this band, it has been almost in the metal scene for almost twenty years (Angel Fall First that I consider their first official release, came out in 1997). Since the inception of the band, they marked in the milestone in the metal scene by setting a foothold for “Symphonic Metal” with other bands such as Therion or Within Temptation.
What was great about Nightwish? The orchestral and synthetic melodics coupled with heavy drums and guitar bass. Who knew that having classical music and heavy metal would marry so great? Well at least Therion gave a try the same year with “Theli” then Nightwish entered the scene. But what Nightwish brought was a voice, an opera-quality voice: Tarja Turonen. It was such a tsunami in the metal sphere that even nowadays they are students taking “Suomi” (Finnish) as college course because of Nightwish.
I got introduced to the Symphonic Metal by listening to Evanescence and the Gathering and I liked it. Then came Tarja and it was the greatest voice I ever heard and I immediately fell in love with Nightwish. It was conciliating my love for classical music and heavy riffs.

But let’s come back to this album. For me, this album is special because it conclude a hiatus I had with the band after they discharged Tarja and took Annette Olzon instead. Honestly I never liked Annette’s voice as Nightwish and also I found their two albums fairly bad. Then they dumped Annette and pick Floor Jansen (ex- After Forever and touring as ReVamp). I liked Floor since After Forever and although she will never replace Tarja she is so far the best pickup from the band (just type Ghost Love Score Tarja and Floor in Youtube). I was disappointed by “Elan” and interested by “Shudder before the most beautiful”. The album just came in, iTunes downloaded for me and pushed it through my “commute test”. First time, I had to have TWO commute tests for this one. I will explain to you later.

What can I say? Oh boy, this one really gave me a hard time because of the secrecy on it and the song pickup for its promo by Tuomas. But it feels like falling again in love for that same girl I was in love during my college years and separated with a tearful time. I really liked it and glad to see Nightwish bringing back the best it was: Orchestral Metal and great opera singer. Some have parted ways from their roots like Lacuna Coil or Within Temptation. They are surely great in the mainstream music scene but no thanks not for me.

The album is really good and despite two three tracks that I did not like such as “Elan, we have a bold and refined Nightwish album, kind a natural continuation to “Once” if you consider everything after Tarja departure as non-canon. Floor is really enjoyable.

But the big thing in that album is this one (and that one that cost me a second commute just for it): “The Greatest show on Earth”, a 25-minutes of pure evasion altering orchestral and acoustic instruments with heavy metal sequences and with Floor unleashing herself (and when she unleash herself, you rather hide your butt because she will kick yours). Imagine 25 minutes, in a single track, the longest track duration I have ever experienced (Epica fairly reach 13-minutes duration). An ode of love for the Nature and for Darwin. A must-listen for any scientists. It is such a pure joy to just sit aside from evolution (and all the molecular mechanisms driving it) and be like Darwin. Watch and appreciate how evolution brought to Earth the greatest show to see: the show of Life. This is just a marvel, tears of joy when Richard Dawkins (that I despise in other times) but I can just like hearing him quoting Darwin:

“Thus, from the war of nature, from famine and death, the most exalted object which we are capable of conceiving, namely, the production of the higher animals, directly follows. There is grandeur in this view of life, with its several powers, having been originally breathed into a few forms or into one; and that, whilst this planet has gone cycling on according to the fixed law of gravity, from so simple a beginning endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful have been, and are being, evolved.”

If I ever have to teach evolution in class again, surely Nightwish would be a recommendation to my students.

My conclusion? A great album, sure with flaws, but with great orchestral arrangements.
My favorite tracks: “Shudder before the Beautiful” and “The Greatest Show On Earth”.


4 thoughts on “[Metal] Nightwish – Endless Forms Most Beautiful (90%)

  1. I’ve ordered the album on disc so haven’t heard it yet. Yes, the first track off the album was a worrying anticlimax, but then Nightwish can’t really be listened to out of context, you have to hear the whole album.

    I think the problem with Anette Olzon was that she was such a big change in the sound of Nightwish, but having listened to Dark Passion Play and Imaginaerum over and over again I’ve come to realise what an amazing voice she did have.

    Anyway, this new album for me is the release of the year and there’ll be a big blog review once I’ve heard it.


    • Thanks Chris,
      Yes definitively, I believe releasing the couple of tracks before the album was very confusing. “Elan” and the like tracks are maybe a couple, you have a couple of songs that sound like “Dark Passion Play” album and you have one third is like a continuation of “Once”.
      But also you can clearly hear the influence of Tuomas “Life and Times of McScrooge Duck” that I found very relaxing and enjoyable to listen. This is what I like about Tuomas, it can make great instrumental songs that let you escape and let your mind imagine. If these tracks were taking me somewhere, it would certainly take me with Darwin aboard the Beagle and witness with him the amazing diversity of Life as he has seen and how millions of year of subtle evolution brought such diversity.


      • I ordered the disk and received the album on MP3 too, so I’ve been listening to it today. Oh dear, I am so disappointed I don’t know what to say! Maybe I need to hear it a few times before it sinks in, but to summarise: some of the tracks are, like Elan, pretty lifeless, and Floor sounds like a session singer. I’ll keep with it, keep listening to it; maybe it’ll grow on me…

        Liked by 1 person

      • I don’t know if you came in with high expectation and thats explain your disappointment. I came with low expectation and was fairly well surprised.
        Have you heard the “Music Inspired by Life and Adventures of McScrooge Duck”? I felt it was the extension of it, in terms of the orchestral arrangement. I really liked this album as a nice ballad symphonic metal and this is I feel we have to take this album. If you are looking for the heaviness, you will be disappointed.
        And also yes, I felt Floor was underutilized in the album except for a couple of tracks. It is not Floor of After Forever and I found it also disappointing but I was getting ready about that when “Elan”, “Sagan” and “Shudder Before The Beautiful”.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s